Tara Leigh Calico BELEN, N.M. Death – Tara Leigh Calico (born February 28, 1969) — a vibrant young college student from Belen, New Mexico — was declared deceased in 1998 after vanishing under mysterious circumstances on September 20, 1988, at the age of 19, in what remains one of New Mexico’s most haunting unsolved cases.
Tara, a 1987 Belen High School graduate and sophomore studying psychology at the University of New Mexico-Valencia campus, was described by family and friends as bright, athletic, kind-hearted and full of promise. On that September morning, she set out from her home on Brugg Street for her daily 36-mile bike ride along State Highway 47, a routine she had followed faithfully. Wearing everyday athletic gear and riding her mother’s neon pink bicycle, she expected to be home in time for tennis with a friend.
What should have been a typical morning turned into lasting sorrow. Tara was last seen near midday and never returned. Despite an extensive search by local law enforcement and later involvement by the FBI, no trace of her or her bicycle was ever found, and her disappearance triggered one of the most enduring mysteries in the region’s history.
In the months following her disappearance, a chilling Polaroid photograph surfaced in Florida depicting a young woman and boy bound and gagged — an image that captivated national attention and sparked speculation that it might show Tara. The photograph’s authenticity was examined by multiple agencies, but no definitive identification was ever made and the individuals in the image remain unidentified.
Tara’s family never stopped seeking answers. Her mother, Patty Doel, who passed away in 2006, held onto hope for years that her daughter might still be alive. Over subsequent decades, family members and friends continued to press for resolution, bringing renewed focus to the case and urging authorities to uncover the truth.
In 2023, the Valencia County Sheriff’s Office announced they had developed new leads and submitted evidence to prosecutors in hopes of bringing charges in connection with Tara’s disappearance — a sign that even after nearly four decades, law enforcement efforts persist.
Though her body was never recovered, and the exact circumstances of her fate remain unknown, Tara Leigh Calico is remembered by those who knew her as an intelligent, spirited young woman whose potential was tragically unfulfilled. Her disappearance continues to inspire investigation, remembrance, and hope that one day, answers will emerge.
Leave a Reply